Stories and gear I actually ride with. Some links earn me a small commission, at no cost to you. Learn more

Best Bike Locks for the City (From a Girl Who Lost 4 Bikes)

After four stolen bikes in NYC and Miami, these are the locks I trust: heavy-duty U-locks, a smart folding lock and a budget pick that still means business.

Heads up: some links on this page are affiliate links. If you buy through them I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read my disclosure.
Best Bike Locks for the City (From a Girl Who Lost 4 Bikes)
The quick verdict

For big cities, get a heavy-duty U-lock like the Kryptonite New York Fahgettaboudit Mini. Pair it with a second lock if you park outside, and never rely on a cable lock alone.

Check price on Amazon →
4.8 Exceptional

Quick picks

Short on time? Here are my favorites at a glance.

  1. Best for NYCKryptonite New York Fahgettaboudit Mini 4.8High-theft neighborhoods and overnight parking
    Check price
  2. Best Overall U-LockABUS Granit X-Plus 540 4.7Everyday commuters who want serious security
    Check price
  3. Best Folding LockABUS Bordo Granit X-Plus 6500 4.5Riders who want flexibility to lock to odd shapes
    Check price
  4. Best ValueKryptonite Evolution Mini-7 4.4Lower-risk areas, quick stops and second locks
    Check price

Side-by-side comparison

Kryptonite New York Fahgettaboudit MiniABUS Granit X-Plus 540ABUS Bordo Granit X-Plus 6500Kryptonite Evolution Mini-7
AwardBest for NYCBest Overall U-LockBest Folding LockBest Value
Rating4.8 4.7 4.5 4.4
Best forHigh-theft neighborhoods and overnight parkingEveryday commuters who want serious securityRiders who want flexibility to lock to odd shapesLower-risk areas, quick stops and second locks
Price$$$$$$$$$$$
Security10.09.58.58.0
Weight5.56.57.07.5
Ease of use7.58.59.08.5
Value8.08.07.59.5
Check priceCheck priceCheck priceCheck price

Scores are out of 10. The highlighted cell is the best in each row.

Kryptonite New York Fahgettaboudit Mini #1
4.8 out of 5
Best for NYC

Kryptonite New York Fahgettaboudit Mini

Best for: High-theft neighborhoods and overnight parking · $$$

This is the lock New Yorkers trust when their bike has to stay outside. The shackle is thick and short, which leaves thieves very little room to work. It's heavy, but that's the point.

Security10.0
Weight5.5
Ease of use7.5
Value8.0

What I love

  • Top-tier security rating
  • Short shackle leaves no room for tools
  • Built for the toughest cities

Keep in mind

  • Heavy to carry
  • Small shackle fits fewer racks
Check price on Amazon →
ABUS Granit X-Plus 540 #2
4.7 out of 5
Best Overall U-Lock

ABUS Granit X-Plus 540

Best for: Everyday commuters who want serious security · $$$

A slightly lighter, smoother everyday U-lock with excellent security. The locking mechanism feels premium, and the size is easy to use on most racks.

Security9.5
Weight6.5
Ease of use8.5
Value8.0

What I love

  • Excellent security for the weight
  • Smooth, reliable key mechanism
  • Fits most racks

Keep in mind

  • Pricey
  • Still heavier than a folding lock
Check price on Amazon →
ABUS Bordo Granit X-Plus 6500 #3
4.5 out of 5
Best Folding Lock

ABUS Bordo Granit X-Plus 6500

Best for: Riders who want flexibility to lock to odd shapes · $$$

Folding locks reach around poles, trees and awkward racks that a U-lock can't. This one is among the toughest folding locks you can buy, and it packs into a neat frame holster.

Security8.5
Weight7.0
Ease of use9.0
Value7.5

What I love

  • Wraps around awkward objects
  • Packs small on your frame
  • Strong security for a folding lock

Keep in mind

  • Expensive
  • Heavier than it looks
Check price on Amazon →
Kryptonite Evolution Mini-7 #4
4.4 out of 5
Best Value

Kryptonite Evolution Mini-7

Best for: Lower-risk areas, quick stops and second locks · $$

A trusted mid-weight U-lock at a fair price, with a cable to secure your front wheel. A great everyday lock, and a smart second lock in high-theft cities.

Security8.0
Weight7.5
Ease of use8.5
Value9.5

What I love

  • Great price for the security
  • Comes with a cable for wheels
  • Easy to carry

Keep in mind

  • Not my pick for overnight NYC parking
Check price on Amazon →

I’ve had four bikes stolen between New York and Miami (I wrote the whole story in Stolen Bikes NYC vs. Miami). Every single time, I learned the same lesson: the lock matters, but how you use it matters even more.

My lock rules

  • Never use a cable lock alone. They can be cut in seconds.
  • Lock the frame, not just the wheel. Run the U-lock through the frame and rear wheel.
  • Use two different locks if your bike stays outside for long. Thieves usually carry one tool.
  • Pick busy, well-lit spots and avoid quiet “dead zones.”
  • Bring it inside whenever you can. That’s why I love my folding bike.

U-lock or folding lock?

U-locks give you the most security for the money. Folding locks are more flexible for awkward racks and poles. If you live in a high-theft city, start with a heavy U-lock and add a second lock later.

Lock types explained

U-locks (D-locks)

A hardened steel shackle shaped like a U. They’re the best security for the money and the first choice for city riding. The downside is weight, and they only fit around certain objects.

Folding locks

Hinged steel plates that fold up small and open into a big loop. They’re more flexible than U-locks and reach around poles, trees and odd racks. Good ones are very secure, but they cost more.

Chain locks

Heavy chains with a padlock. Thick chains are very secure and flexible, but they’re heavy and not fun to carry on your bike.

Cable locks

Thin, flexible cables. Easy to cut in seconds. Only use them as a second lock to secure your wheels or seat, never alone.

How to read security ratings

Many brands rate their locks on their own scale (for example, a number out of 10 or 15). These are useful for comparing locks within one brand, but not across brands.

Independent ratings from testing organizations are more reliable when you can find them. In general, look for:

  • A thicker shackle (13mm or more for high-theft areas).
  • Hardened steel.
  • A quality locking mechanism that’s hard to pick.
  • A short shackle that leaves thieves little room to use tools.

How to lock your bike the right way

  1. Choose a solid, fixed object. A proper bike rack is best. Avoid poles that can be unscrewed or signposts a bike can be lifted over.
  2. Lock your frame and rear wheel together with your U-lock.
  3. Secure your front wheel with a second lock or a cable, or take it with you.
  4. Fill the U-lock’s space. Less room inside the lock means less room for a thief’s tools.
  5. Keep the lock off the ground so it can’t be smashed against the pavement.
  6. Take everything removable: lights, bags, quick-release seat.

Extra theft protection

  • Register your bike with your local police or a bike registry, and write down the serial number.
  • Take photos of your bike and keep your receipt.
  • Consider a hidden GPS tracker for expensive bikes.
  • Use locking skewers for wheels and seats.
  • Make your bike less attractive with stickers or tape. Shiny new bikes get stolen first.
  • Look into insurance for pricey bikes. Some renters’ or home policies cover bikes.

What to do if your bike is stolen

I’ve been there four times, so here’s what I learned:

  1. Report it to the police right away. You’ll need a report for insurance.
  2. Post it on local social media groups and bike registries.
  3. Check online marketplaces for listings that match your bike.
  4. Call local bike shops. Thieves sometimes try to sell parts.
  5. Take care of yourself. It hurts. It’s okay to be sad about it.

FAQ

How much should I spend on a lock?

A common rule is 10% to 20% of your bike’s value, or more if you live in a high-theft city.

Is a heavier lock always better?

Not always, but in general thicker steel is harder to cut. Balance security with how much weight you’re willing to carry.

Can thieves cut any lock?

With enough time and the right tools, yes. The goal is to make your bike harder to steal than the bikes around it.

My bottom line

Buy the best lock you can afford, ideally around 10% of what your bike is worth or more, and use it well every time.

N

Written by Nesli

I’m Nesli, the girl on the bike. I’ve ridden city streets for 14 years, first in New York and now in Miami, and I share what I’ve learned along the way. How I pick products →

Keep reading