
The Segway Ninebot MAX G2 is the best all-round commuter scooter thanks to its long range and comfy suspension. For short trips on a budget, the Hiboy S2 is hard to beat.
Quick picks
Short on time? Here are my favorites at a glance.
Side-by-side comparison
Segway Ninebot MAX G2 | Segway Ninebot F2 | Hiboy S2 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Award | Best Overall | Best Mid-Range | Best Budget |
| Rating | 4.7 | 4.5 | 4.2 |
| Best for | Daily commuters with longer trips | Medium commutes on a sensible budget | Short trips and first-time scooter riders |
| Price | $$$ | $$ | $ |
| Range | 9.5 | 8.0 | 7.0 |
| Comfort | 9.0 | 8.0 | 7.0 |
| Portability | 6.0 | 7.0 | 8.0 |
| Value | 8.5 | 9.0 | 9.5 |
| Check price | Check price | Check price |
Scores are out of 10. The highlighted cell is the best in each row.
#1 Segway Ninebot MAX G2
Best for: Daily commuters with longer trips · $$$
Long range, front and rear suspension and big tires make this the scooter I'd recommend to most city commuters. It feels stable and planted on rough roads.
What I love
- Long real-world range
- Smooth suspension
- Stable, confident ride
Keep in mind
- Heavy to carry upstairs
#2 Segway Ninebot F2
Best for: Medium commutes on a sensible budget · $$
A lighter, more affordable Segway that still feels solid. A great middle ground between range and portability.
What I love
- Good range for the price
- Lighter than the MAX
- Trusted brand
Keep in mind
- Less suspension than the MAX G2
#3 Hiboy S2
Best for: Short trips and first-time scooter riders · $
An affordable way to try scooter commuting. It's fine for short, smooth trips, and it folds easily for small spaces.
What I love
- Very affordable
- Easy to fold
- Simple app
Keep in mind
- Feels bumpy on rough roads
- Shorter range
Lately, I ride my scooter more than my bike. It doesn’t give me quite the same flow, but it still gives me freedom, and in the Miami heat, arriving without sweating is a gift.
What to look for
- Real-world range: expect less than the box says, especially with hills or heavier riders.
- Suspension and tire size: they matter a lot on potholes.
- Weight: if you’ll carry it upstairs, lighter is better.
- Brakes and lights: you need both for city traffic.
Scooter vs bike for city life
| E-scooter | Bike | |
|---|---|---|
| Effort | Almost none | You pedal |
| Sweat factor | Low | Higher (hello, Miami heat) |
| Storage | Folds small | Needs more space |
| Range | Limited by battery | Unlimited |
| Exercise | Very little | Great workout |
| Freedom | Easy, quick trips | The flow I love |
Key specs explained
Range
Brands list a maximum range, but real-world range is usually lower. Rider weight, hills, speed mode, wind and temperature all reduce it. A good rule is to expect about 60% to 70% of the advertised range.
Motor power
More watts usually means better acceleration and easier hills. For flat cities like Miami, a mid-range motor is plenty. For hilly cities, look for more power.
Top speed
Most commuter scooters top out around 15 to 20 mph. Check your local laws, because many cities limit e-scooter speeds and where you can ride.
Tires
- Pneumatic (air-filled) tires are smoother and grip better, but can get flats.
- Solid tires never go flat, but they feel much bumpier.
- Self-healing tires are a nice middle ground.
Suspension
Front and rear suspension make a huge difference on bumpy city streets. If your roads have potholes, prioritize suspension.
Weight
Heavier scooters are more stable and have bigger batteries. Lighter scooters are easier to carry up stairs and onto transit.
Safety essentials
- Wear a helmet. Every single ride. See my favorite helmets.
- Use lights, both front and rear, even during the day.
- Ride defensively. Assume drivers don’t see you.
- Watch for potholes and wet roads. Small wheels can catch.
- Keep both hands on the handlebars and don’t text while riding.
- Follow local rules about bike lanes, sidewalks and speed limits.
Battery care
- Charge it at room temperature, not in a hot car or in direct sun.
- Don’t leave it at 0% for long periods.
- Use the original charger.
- Store it indoors. Heat and humidity shorten battery life.
- Never charge a damaged battery, and don’t charge it overnight unattended.
Theft protection for scooters
Scooters are easy to steal. Bring yours inside whenever you can. If you must lock it, use a sturdy lock through the frame, not the folding stem. My lock guide has picks that work for scooters too.
FAQ
Are e-scooters legal in my city?
Rules vary by city and state. Check where you’re allowed to ride, speed limits and whether helmets are required.
Can I ride an e-scooter in the rain?
Many scooters have water resistance ratings, but riding in heavy rain is risky. Wet roads mean less grip, and water can damage electronics.
How long does a scooter battery last?
With good care, scooter batteries usually last a few years before range drops noticeably.
Ride safe
Wear a helmet (here are my favorite cute ones), use bike lanes where you can and assume every car is about to do something unexpected.


